The Knowledge, a Stellar Murder Mystery by Martha Grimes

Martha Grimes writes wonderful mysteries featuring Scotland Yard detective Richard Jury and his oddball friends. With The Knowledge, she has completely outdone herself, and Patty Haigh is the reason why. Patty is the most fascinating child protagonist ever, which is all I will say about her because readers deserve the pleasure of discovering Patty for themselves. I won’t even attempt to describe Patty or the part she plays in this wildly fun murder mystery which careens back and forth between London and Kenya and features wild animals, precious jewels, diabolical villains and some truly endearing loyalties.

We can all use some diversion about now, and The Knowledge, featuring Patty Haigh, is perfect! What a discovery!

An Excellent Mystery Set in 19th Century England

Chris Nickson’s Gods of Gold is a wonderfully atmospheric murder mystery set in Leeds, England in 1890. Tom Harper is a police detective who has aspirations for upward mobility and personal happiness — he is engaged to Annabelle Atkinson, a young widow entrepreneur, who clearly deserves her own mystery series.

However, Gods of Gold belongs to Tom Harper, who tries to find a missing girl and solve some nasty murders in the face of political corruption and a nasty labor strike. Despite power brokers who are more concerned with the controlling the strike and preserving their particular version of “the peace,” Harper keeps working his cases and trying to find the girl. He may not be brilliant, but he has worked his way up to a good position. Risk aversion is alien to many murder mystery detectives, so it is interesting to see how Harper nudges and works the system and tries to stay out of too much trouble. He takes risks, but he also attempts to manage those risks, both to himself and to those around him. Incidentally, the characters around Harper are particularly well written — the supporting cast is strong.

Gods of Gold offers police work in a different age. Class distinctions are important, and forensic science has barely scratched the surface. Yet the politics of career survival for a detective who wants to triage his own work load rings very true.

Chris Nickson does a magnificent job of describing nineteen century Leeds. The grim poverty presided over by corrupt and “respectable” local power brokers is keenly observed. Still, there is time to appreciate what it meant to be a young man working his way up without benefit of an education. I also loved Annabelle Atkinson, Harper’s fiancée and her ambitions.

I liked this book, and hope to read more Tom Harper books. Gods of Gold is the first of a series of six mysteries, by a very prolific writer who not only writes other detective series, but seems to have spent much of the 1990’s writing celebrity biographies.

The Marshal at the Villa Torrini, An Excellent Florentine Mystery by Magdalen Nabb

Magdalen Nabb wrote an excellent series of mysteries set in Florence and featuring Marshal Guarnaccia. The Marshal at the Villa Torrini is one of her best. Her police detective Marshal Guarnaccia is not suave and sophisticated, and he doesn’t always have all that much confidence in himself, all of which makes following along as he unravels odd clues and interviews an eccentric and highly diverse cast of witnesses a true pleasure. He is a nice, occasionally ornery guy with a purposeful, sensitive way of dealing with his witnesses. He is a bit of an outsider himself as he has transferred to Florence from Sicily.

So many mysteries present a terrific urgency in finding the killer and the prevention of further mayhem as bodies pile up. The Marshal at the Villa Torrini presents a calmer, more patient approach. There is one murder to solve, and Guarnaccia goes about his business thoughtfully as he waits for evidence to be collected and figures out how he can nail the culprit. He also has a brand new side kick who turns out be pretty adorable.

The Marshall at the Villa Torrini is not a comic mystery, but it offers a lot of well-placed humor. Florence is the perfect setting. Nabb’s constant references to dramatic and oppressive weather, as well as to a more mundane local court proceeding really add flavor and context. Guarnaccia’s round of witness interviews takes the reader all around Florence and offers a wonderful and often comic mix of personalities and circumstances. Nabb also gets high marks for presenting a new and different cause of death!

Magdalen Nabb was born in England and lived in Florence. She died in 2007, and left a legacy of some very fine books. They are concise, moving and highly intelligent.